The three main structural problems with the senate in canada

On the other hand, it gave Senators an absolute veto over natural resources and French language and culture. Recently he stated that, while he supports the Triple-E Senate in principle, he would only commit to consulting with provinces on how to select new Senators.

Development of new systems[ edit ] Jean-Charles de Borda proposed the Borda count in as a method for electing members to the French Academy of Sciences.

Canada's Senate Problems: From Brazeau, To Duffy, To Zimmerberger

In the United States in the earlyth-century progressive erasome municipalities began to use Bucklin votingalthough this is no longer used in any government elections, and has even been declared unconstitutional in Minnesota. Rhode Island is only one voice in fifty, as opposed to one in ten.

Put aside also that it may have been equally improper for Wright to make the payment. This system is used in Sri Lankan presidential elections, with voters allowed to give three preferences.

Should the Senate have the power to ratify or veto federal appointments to national regulatory agencies and the Supreme Court.

Changes To The Canadian Senate

Third and I hate to keep harping on this Mike Duffy should have never been appointed to the Senate in the first place — at least not to represent P. Following the collapse of the Meech Lake Accord, Alberta held a provincial election The three main structural problems with the senate in canada fill a vacant Senate seat.

Variations of this include the Additional Member System and Alternative Vote Plusin which voters rank candidates, and the other from multi-member constituencies elected on a proportional party list basis.

Expenses Scandal In November the Senate voted to suspend Conservative senators Mike Duffy, Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau, as part of a widening scandal into alleged improper expense claims for housing and travel allowances by these and dozens of other Conservative and Liberal senators.

This accord was defeated in the referendum held in This system does not use any consistent logic, which is one of the reasons why the Senate is so controversial. However, in most cases several multi-member constituencies are used rather than a single nationwide constituency, giving an element of geographical representation.

Accordingly, Prime Minister Stephen Harper in recommended the appointment of Bert Brownwho was elected in Alberta's Senator in waiting election, [19] but otherwise followed the standing rules in the absence of other elected nominees.

Electoral system

Nor was he appointed because of his detailed knowledge of the problems facing P. In addition, instead of rejecting a bill, the Senate can simply choose not to vote on it. TKN is "superior in terms of content.

As the Pepin-Robarts report states, it is a means "…of institutionalizing the processes of executive federalism…within the parliamentary process.

It was presented as a package deal: The amendments it does make to bills now are almost always related to drafting — to clarify, simplify and tidy proposed legislation.

Canadian Senate problems go far beyond Mike Duffy: Walkom

Senate investigations have often led to important changes in government policy or legislation. One of his appointments was Bert Brownwho was one of Alberta's elected nominees and is the second unofficially elected senator in Canadian history after Stan Waters in They in turn elected a final electoral body of 41 members, who ultimately elected the Doge.

As of December 14, there were 22 Senate vacancies. Biproportional apportionment is a system whereby the total number of votes is used to calculate the number of seats each party is due, followed by a calculation of the constituencies in which the seats should be awarded in order to achieve the total due to them.

At the time the Canadian Constitution was written, there was still relatively high levels of distrust for democracy within the Canadian political establishment, and it was considered important for there to be some level of government that could overrule what were assumed to be the occasionally dumb or dangerous ideas of politicians elected by poor or uneducated voters.

About the Senate What is the Senate. Parliament of Canada website. Furthermore, the fact that there are fifty states means these variations have less impact.

Brazeau, Duffy and former Liberal senator Mac Harb were also charged with alleged crimes including fraud and breach of trust in relation to the expense scandal.

Should the Senate have the power to initiate legislation. In the United Statesthe president is indirectly elected using a two-stage process; a popular vote in each state elects members to the electoral college that in turn elects the President.

Why Canada needs the Senate

In Greece the party receiving the most votes is given an additional 50 seats, [6] San Marino has a modified two-round system, which sees a second round of voting featuring the top two parties or coalitions if there is no majority in the first round.

By drawing lots, a body of 30 electors was chosen, which was further reduced to nine electors by drawing lots again.

About the Senate

The bill would have limited Senate terms to nine years, and allowed provinces to elect their senators, if they chose to do so. Weighted systems are still used in corporate elections, with votes weighted to reflect stock ownership.

Although not constitutionally bound to do so, Brian Mulroney appointed the nominee, Stan Watersto the Senate in An exhaustive ballot is not limited to two rounds, but sees the last-placed candidate eliminated in the round of voting.

Proceedings in the Senate chamber, and the proceedings of most senate committees, are open to public viewing. Votes are then reallocated from the least successful candidates until the number of candidates that have passed the quota is equal to the number of seats to be filled.

Similar limits are placed on candidacy also known as passive suffrageand in many cases the age limit for candidates is higher than the voting age. Party-list proportional representation is the single most common electoral system and is used by 80 countries, and involves voters voting for a list of candidates proposed by a party.

On the other hand, Senators could not claim to be representing the interests of provincial governments. Basic Problems with Non-Constitutional Senate Reform When it comes to the three main areas where reform is proposed - method of selecting senators, regional representation, and powers - the only one that can be achieved by non-constitutional means is the method of selecting Senators.

The Senate's purpose is to consider and revise legislation, investigate national issues, and most crucially according to the Constitution — give the regions of Canada an equal voice in Parliament. The Senate is the Upper House of Canada's Parliament.

The three problems with the Canadian senate There are three problems, of which the third is the most serious. Donald Trump threatens to terminate NAFTA if Congress stands up for Canada. This takes two main forms; with voters allowed to give three preferences.

The other main form of majoritarian system is the two-round system, Similar problems in Belarus led to the parliamentary elections going to a fourth round of voting before enough parliamentarains were elected to make a quorum.

The official site of the Senate of Canada. Learn about the “Red Chamber” and keep track of senators’ work on bills, committee studies and current affairs. About the Senate The Senate is the Upper House in Canada’s bicameral parliamentary democracy. It unites a diverse group of accomplished Canadians in service of .

The three main structural problems with the senate in canada
Rated 0/5 based on 61 review
Senate of Canada - Wikipedia